Fulfillment FOMO
And alternative paths to passion. What to do when “find your passion” fails. [Not Obvious: Part 5]
The Way of Work explores stories of where we fit in the world of work. This is part of the series, Not Obvious, exploring why work advice fails us:
Part 1: Why Work Advice Fails Us (intro)
Part 2: Burnout, Balance, and the Bullshit in Between (on “hard work”)
Part 3: You Will Never Feel Done (on “productivity”)
Part 4: Welcome to Management: Please Proceed With Delusions of Control (on “management”)
Has any advice created as much hopeless misery as “find your passion”?
Modern workers are infected with a disease: Fulfillment FOMO.
The gnawing anxiety that you’re not quite where you’re supposed to be. That something better is out there, just beyond your grasp. You’re in the wrong job, the wrong career, maybe even the wrong life. And if you haven’t found it? You’re stuck with visions of what could be.
For a while, I bought into the hype, believing that others had it all figured out. Not anyone I knew personally, but people were out there, for sure! They told me they were living their perfect life and I bought it:
“Do what you love and the money will follow.”
But I’ve come to see this as the online version of a late-night infomercial selling miracle juice. A classic bait-and-switch: vague enough to intrigue, empty enough to disappoint.
The problem is that the alternative – suppressing your dreams – sounds way worse. So we’re supposed to endure a life of drudgery, meaninglessness, and regret? That’s what life is like?
In a choice between heaven and hell, we’re holding out hope for a heaven. So we continue on with Fulfillment FOMO, overlooking that purpose might be found in paths that don’t require a perfect fit. I explore those alternatives later.
The career fantasy that won’t set you free
I blame Ikigai.
Even if you don’t recognize the word, you already know the promise:
Do what you love.
Do what you’re good at.
Do what the world needs.
And get paid for it.
Ikigai dangles a fantasy in front of your face: a “sweet spot” where your ideal life is custom-fitted, purpose-filled, and waiting just for you.
It’s a beautifully simple formula for fulfillment… until it becomes a high-stakes hunt for the holy grail, where any wrong move results in failure.
If your work doesn’t check all the boxes, you’re settling. You’re successful, but unfulfilled. You love your work, but never make enough money. You’re doing what the world wants, but not what you want. You haven’t searched hard enough, self-reflected enough, or micro-dosed enough.
While Ikigai is theoretically possible, in reality, it’s a perfectionist’s nightmare:
“…this diagram frankly had the opposite effect, it was paralyzing. It made me miserable, and I wasted a lot of time trying to figure it out… What is my ‘one thing’ at the center of my universe that meets all these criteria? I thought about it a few different ways, but ended up giving up in frustration.” - , from Ikigai Ruined My Life
The concept of Ikigai (and others like it) sells you a fairy tale and then makes you feel like an idiot for not living up to it. For many, it doesn’t solve career anxiety, it creates it. The framework is right, just you aren’t.
The main problem, as I see it, is you can rarely jam a paycheck into a passion, let alone get the stars to align across all four categories.
“The truth is that the market doesn’t give a damn about your calling. You’re deluding yourself if you believe the system is organized around helping you find your perfect work.” - from When you don’t have a “calling”
And even if you find your thing, who says it will last forever? Most athletic careers are over soon after they begin; even Tom Brady (at 47) needs to figure out his next act. Artists have short creative peaks; there’s more one-hit-wonders than Billy Joels. Founders (who I salute but whose contentment is over-glorified) work themselves out of what they love when they sell their company (if they’re lucky), scale so big they no longer do what they love, or burnout in the process.
Callings, Ikigai, or whatever you want to call them, are actually quite fragile. Because no one tells you the small print: results may vary.
Paths to Passion
So if the apex is out of reach, now what? Do we settle for a joyless grind? Accept that work will always suck? I don’t think that’s the right answer either.
Because fulfilled people do exist! I know a few. Maybe you know some too. But in my experience, they find meaning, not nirvana. And it’s that slightly-lower-than-heaven part that’s a bit more in reach for the rest of us.
So at the risk of tearing down a flawed diagram, and then replacing it with my own flawed diagram, I’m going to share some options (not answers) I’ve noticed over time. I’ve studied people on these paths, especially looking to understand the trade-offs, not just the sugar coated sales pitch. There may be more options or more precise options-within-the-options or ways to remix them and so on. Naming this type of thing is an imprecise science (hey, just like finding your passion, which is kinda my point…).
So with full awareness that I might be doing exactly what I just critiqued, here are some imperfect, but real, paths to passion:
The Practical Path
Here, work is primarily practical and transactional. We first orient toward opportunities profit (e.g. income and savings). Passion is put on hold until later, either because it hasn’t revealed itself yet or because financial independence is required first.
“Anyone who tells you to follow your passion is already rich.” – Scott Galloway
Strengths
Financial stability: income is predictable, bills get paid
Clear trajectory: structured paths, makes planning easier
Skill-building: can find fulfillment from mastery over-time
Trade-offs
Life deferral: “I’ll do what I love later,” but later may never come
No guarantees: that patience will be rewarded
Habit-forming: you might never pivot (never knowing enough), career exits (voluntary or not) can become an existential crisis
Examples: stability-first careers (e.g. lawyers, doctors, accountants), FIRE (e.g. MadFientist), later career passion pursuers (e.g. Sara Pendergast, Cathy Foerster, me?)
Read next: Waiting Decades to Finally Follow Your Dreams
The Passion Bet
The leap now, figure-it-out later path. They prioritize fulfillment over finances, jumping headfirst into work they love, even if it doesn’t pay well (or at all). It’s not that money doesn’t matter, but it’s secondary to doing something meaningful.
"Follow your bliss and the universe will open doors where there were only walls." – Joseph Campbell
Strengths
Live now: no waiting or deferral, intrinsic motivation can fuel long-term persistence
Less regret: don’t have to wake up later wondering “what if?” (at least the passion part)
Potential upside: if break through, the rewards can be big (financial or otherwise)
Trade-offs
Financial instability: many struggle for years (or forever)
No ladders: lack of defined paths to success
Social outlier: can appear too risky or irresponsible to outsiders
Examples: creatives, artists, activists, mission-driven workers
Read next: The Pathless Path by
The Work-Life Split
The work-to-live path. Work is a means that pays the bills, funds interests, and, ideally, takes up as little time and mental space as possible. Passion isn’t monetized or careerized, it exists separately from any job.
"Not everything you love should be turned into a career. Some things are better left as hobbies." — Paul Jarvis
Strengths
Unlimited passion options: because passions don’t need to pay
Clarity in work’s purpose: it just has to fund life + take as little time as possible
Like with like: no need to force passion into work (or vice versa)
Trade-offs
Partial passions: must fit into the margins of the day
Job is a slog: work feels like a distraction away from what you really want
Either/or thinking: over-compartmentalize, not realizing that work can sometimes be fulfilling even if it’s not a passion
Examples: 9-5er who’s an artist on the side, weekend warriors, amateur hobbyists
Read next: The Good Enough Job by
The Passion Pivot
Like The Practical Path, but with less waiting. Instead of grinding toward financial independence, they build career capital (which creates a base), then pivot toward passion when they have enough leverage. Rather than climbing a single career ladder forever, they trade wins for freedom; shaping their work on their own terms, sometimes one move at a time. Money isn’t the goal; it’s the bridge to something better.
"Become so good they can’t ignore you. Then, use that leverage to do what excites you." — Cal Newport
Strengths
Have it both ways: build security, but don’t wait forever
Accelerated: to partial-freedom at midlife where you choose work you prefer
Optionality: once you gain leverage, you have more choices
Trade-offs
$$$ left on the table: pivot during peak earning years (a crime against capitalism!)
Living in limbo: not maximizing either side, no single-minded clarity
“What if?”: should you have gone all-in earlier or waited a little longer?
Examples: Successful-to-independents (e.g.
, ), Portfolio Careers (e.g. ), CoastFIRERead next: Just Enough to Walk Away
Which trade-offs could you live with? What do you think I missed or messed up? Let me know in the comments.
Let go of the FOMO
The happiest people I know have made peace with imperfection. They shift between priorities, adjust to life’s trade-offs, and adapt instead of agonizing. They build a life that works for them, not one that fits neatly inside a Venn diagram.
I’m not going to claim any one choice is right. Every path has risks. Exactly zero are easy. But the biggest risk may be wasting your life chasing something theoretically possible, but practically out of reach.
Careers evolve (and end). Interests change. What excites you at 25 might bore you at 50. There’s rarely a "eureka moment," but always another step forward.
It turns out you can live out your passion. Just maybe not in the perfect, heavenly form you hoped for.
And if you are able to pair your passion with a paycheck… then go for it! Just think twice before you tell all of us it’s possible too.
Bonus: Ambiguous Advice
▸ “Just do what you love and the money will follow.”
- guy selling B2B accounting software.
▸ "The only way to do great work is to love what you do." – Steve Jobs
Steve, I’m so glad tech guys understand this. Because I really love my work and excited for a long, stable career at USAID.
▸ "Look for a job you love, and you will never have to work a day in your life."
Because they aren’t hiring.1
▸ “Find your calling.”
My calling is to not work, then come back and tell you all about it.
Next up, I’ll be exploring the office politics.
If you’ve enjoyed The Way of Work: comment, ❤️ or 🔄 below and/or share it with a friend.
This is not my joke, but I can’t find a source to attribute it to.
The whole idea that we have innate passions that can be unearthed by simply looking inward is flawed. Sure, there are examples of people who found their passion or purpose early, but 1) the discovery happened by getting out there and trying stuff, and 2) a fair amount of luck plays into when someone gets exposure to what ends up being a passion/purpose. The trick is to try a ton of $h!t and embrace being terrible for a while. The interest won't be strong enough in most things to push past the "I'm terrible at this" stage, but every once in a while it will be, and that's where the magic happens. I think I've heard Josh Waitzkin talk about how passion comes much later after you've already worked at something for a long time, once proficiency is starting to compound. Basically the opposite of how we're told it works.
Love the quadrant, by the way. I'm working on a piece right now about trade-offs so it really landed.
My “variation on the Ikigai theme”: love what you do and do it well, and your life will be alright.